Training is a Terrible Word
The other day I was speaking with a client about the training courses that SunShower offers. I heard myself say, “but training is just a terrible word, isn’t it?” She laughed and agreed. We joked that training is for dogs and maybe some cats. It was funny, and, as I thought about it afterwards, I have to say that there is something to using the word (and approach) training – especially in the area of Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion.
Do we want to train people in Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion? Do we want people to simply perform what we train them to do? Or do we want people to learn and grow?
It got me thinking about training and that I decided that I’d like to use a better word, education. The next day, as sometimes happens, an article by Amna Khalid and Jeffrey Aaron Snyder came across my feed. This excellent article addresses training versus education directly. Here’s an excerpt.
“Here are some things training is good for: customer service, Excel and CPR. One thing it’s not good for: diversity, equity, and inclusion. At a time when trainings are proliferating across institutions of higher learning, people could be forgiven for confusing training with education. But they are vastly different and should be seen as such especially when it comes to issues of diversity. The purpose of education, bell hooks reminds us, is critical thinking. Requiring “courage and imagination,” the “heartbeat of critical thinking is the longing to know — to understand how life works.” With Hooks’s words in mind, here are 10 ways to tell training and education apart.
- Training makes assumptions; education challenges them.
- Training is packaged; education cannot be contained.
- Training rewards compliance, education curiosity.
- Training is having to say something, education having something to say.
- Training tells you what to think; education teaches you how to think.
- Training answers questions; education poses them.
- Training is generic; education all about context.
- Training simplifies the world; education reveals its complexity.
- Training promotes conformity, education independence.
- Training is performative; education is transformative.
Training has its uses. It can even save lives. (See CPR above.) But training is woefully inadequate when it comes to confronting social problems such as poverty, discrimination and racism. These are long-standing, knotty, and complex issues that defy ready-made solutions. Any serious effort to address them must start with education, a process for which there are no shortcuts.”
The authors continue by laying out two hypothetical examples of how to deal with issues of race and diversity with the two approaches, training and then education. It’s worth reading the entire article.
More From Our Blog…
For the past 6 months, I’ve been working on my e-Learning courses to make them accessible for all learners. This has been quite a journey. I used to think that I had a handle on accessibility as long as I added captions to my videos. But that was just a very small...
“It's hard to imagine an economy driven by Latino and Latina growth when leadership at the board level and in the C-suite is far less than 5% Latino and Latina. That gap - between the face of leadership and the face of the economy to come - is a vast strategic issue...
To be human is to be flawed, but our struggles have the remarkable potential to transform us. By addressing our mistakes and remaining open to learning, we broaden our understanding, increase our empathy and build our capacity to do better the next time. ...
“I can’t say anything anymore”. That was the complaint from a participant in an online workshop on microaggressions. We had just watched a montage that weaves together common microaggressions and expressions of confusion and pain among those targeted and bystanders....
The “Great Resignation” continues along its historic path with 47.8 million workers quitting their jobs in 2021, which represented a record-setting average of nearly 4 million each month. As of March 2022, 8.6 million people quit their jobs this year. ...
Article written by Gina Miller: Gina Miller has committed herself to social justice for over a decade through her writing and community activism. She and her husband have led educational programs, service projects, dialogue workshops, blogs and rallies through...