Shrill

You don’t have to be a keen observer of culture to notice that certain words and descriptions have become code-words to criticize and marginalize women and dismiss their ideas. To monitor how your own unconscious biases may be at play in your communications, you’ll need to pay attention to the hidden messages that words can carry.

Strident. Aggressive. Pushy. When these code-words are hurled at a woman, they are coming from a historical norm that says women must be seen and not heard, soft, docile. Quite often these words are used to criticize a woman’s style and the speaker is trying not to look like they’re making a direct criticism. But it’s just a smokescreen because the impact is hurtful and marginalizing.

Shrill is in a category of its own.

Real example. I was speaking with a guy about a female candidate. He said, “I would support her, but I don’t think she can win. Her voice is just so shrill.” I pointed out how “shrill” is loaded. Are her policies good? He said they were good, but he defended his position by doubling down, “Just listen, she is shrill and it will turn everyone off and she won’t win”. There was no room to talk about the hidden (not so hidden) message and the hypocrisy of “I would support her, but….”. So, imagine if a male candidate had a high voice, would my friend have used the word shrill? I doubt it.

Which leads me to Wiley. This strip says it all. Done.

So, let’s look in the mirror. If you hear yourself use a word like shrill to describe a woman, take a moment to consider why you chose that word. Are you really talking about the person’s voice and style? Consider if using that word is a sign of a bias. Self-reflection is critical in the personal work to be respectful and inclusive.

While clearly similar code words are directed towards people of color and members of other marginalized groups, in this post, I want to bring attention to the words used against women.

Switching things up is a great technique to check your bias – switch the gender of the subject and see if your description still works.

  • I like our new sales manager but she’s so emotional when she speaks.
  • I like our new sales manager, he’s so passionate when he speaks.

I came across a blog post that goes deeper into shrill – “In praise of strident women”. In this article, debuk, writes about “code-words which have become covertly gendered because of the way they’re most commonly used”. It’s a brilliant post and I hope you’ll read it to go deeper.

From the post, “Though in principle they are applicable to anyone who speaks in a certain way, in practice they are used significantly more frequently to criticize the speech of women and girls. It doesn’t necessarily matter how the target of this criticism actually speaks, because what’s couched as a complaint about her speech style is really just a way of complaining about the woman or girl herself, while making the speaker’s antipathy to her appear to have some reasonable or ‘objective’ basis. (‘I’m fine with women holding office/ making speeches/ leading movements…it’s just that this particular woman’s voice/speaking style is so horrendously [insert code-word here].’)”

More From Our Blog…

How To Be an Ally in the Workplace

How To Be an Ally in the Workplace

Article written by Gina Miller: Gina Miller has committed herself to social justice for over a decade through her writing and community activism.  She and her husband have led educational programs, service projects, dialogue workshops, blogs and rallies through the...

read more
SunShower is a Communicator Award winner

SunShower is a Communicator Award winner

The 21-Day Plan for Disarming Microaggressions with Dr. Derald Wing Sue has been selected by the Academy of Interactive and Visual Arts to be recognized as a Communicator Award winner!  It’s a wonderful honor and we’re thrilled that this online,...

read more
Toxic behavior that affects morale and retention

Toxic behavior that affects morale and retention

I came across an article in Fast Company (LINK) by Melinda Briana Epler, the author of How to Be an Ally: Actions You Can Take for a Stronger, Happier, Workplace. Melinda makes many excellent points about microaggressions and non-verbal bullying. She writes about the...

read more
Wait, was that a microaggression?

Wait, was that a microaggression?

I just discovered a new online encyclopedia of microaggressions. It lists specific examples of microaggressions and debriefs why they are harmful. Check out Micropedia here. I found it to be very interesting and useful. Micropedia lists microaggressions pertaining to...

read more